Nearleap vs HomeAdvisor for Painters: Which Is Better?
Compare Nearleap and HomeAdvisor for Painting leads. Pricing, lead quality, and ROI analysis for Painters.
Painting contractors face intense competition in every market. With average projects around $2,500 and numerous painters competing for work, lead generation efficiency determines business success. Wasted leads mean wasted time and money.
HomeAdvisor has served painters for over two decades. Nearleap offers a modern alternative built to address contractor frustrations. This comparison examines both platforms for painting professionals.
Platform Overview
Nearleap Model
Exclusive leads at fixed prices without monthly fees:
Pricing:
- Pro: $25/lead
- Business: $22/lead
- Enterprise: $19/lead
Features:
- 100% exclusivity
- No contracts
- Credit rollover
- Transparent pricing
HomeAdvisor Model
Monthly fees plus per-lead charges with shared distribution:
Pricing:
- Monthly membership: $200-300
- Per-lead: $10-40 for painting
- Leads shared with 3-4 painters
- Advertising options additional
Cost Breakdown
Nearleap (20 leads, Business)
- Leads: $600
- Fees: $0
- Total: $600
- Exclusive opportunities: 20
HomeAdvisor (20 leads, standard)
- Membership: $250
- Leads at $25 avg: $500
- Basic advertising: $100
- Total: $850
- Viable after sharing: 5-7
Cost Per Opportunity
Nearleap: $30 HomeAdvisor: $121-170
Lead Quality
Nearleap
Qualification:
- Contact verified
- Scope confirmed
- Budget validated
- Timeline established
Metrics:
- 77% contact rate
- 51% estimate requests
- 24% close rate
HomeAdvisor
Generation:
- Mass advertising
- SEO/SEM
- Partner referrals
Qualification:
- Basic forms
- Category matching
- Location filtering
Metrics:
- 55% contact rate
- 38% estimate requests
- 14% close rate
User Experience
Nearleap
- Clean dashboard
- 15 minutes daily
- No response pressure
- Mobile optimized
HomeAdvisor
- Complex platform
- 1+ hour daily
- Immediate response critical
- Multiple features to manage
Pros and Cons
Nearleap
Pros:
- Exclusive leads
- Fixed pricing
- No monthly fees
- Higher close rates
- Time efficient
Cons:
- Higher per-lead cost
- Lower volume
- Newer platform
HomeAdvisor
Pros:
- High volume available
- Established brand
- Extensive resources
Cons:
- Shared leads
- Monthly fees
- Response pressure
- Annual commitments
- Complex pricing
ROI Projections
Nearleap Annual
- Investment: $7,200
- Leads: 240 exclusive
- Closes (24%): 58 jobs
- Revenue: $145,000
- Cost per close: $124
- ROI: 20:1
HomeAdvisor Annual
- Investment: $10,200
- Leads: 240 shared (60 viable)
- Closes (14%): 8 jobs
- Revenue: $20,000
- Cost per close: $1,275
- ROI: 2:1
Selection Criteria
Nearleap Best For:
- Average projects $1,500+
- Close rates above 18%
- Time-limited operations
- Predictable budget needs
- Quality preference
HomeAdvisor Best For:
- Volume priority
- Dedicated response staff
- Price-based competition
- Multi-service operations
- Annual commitment acceptable
Final Verdict
Painters achieve 10x better ROI with Nearleap versus HomeAdvisor. The shared lead model devastates painting contractor economics.
Key comparisons:
- Cost per close: $124 vs $1,275
- Jobs closed: 58 vs 8
- Investment: $7,200 vs $10,200
- ROI: 20:1 vs 2:1
Recommendation: Painters should make Nearleap primary lead source. HomeAdvisor's monthly fees and shared leads make sustainable profitability extremely difficult.
FAQ
Does HomeAdvisor offer exclusive painting leads?
Exclusive options exist at premium rates (2-3x standard), plus monthly membership still required. Poor value compared to Nearleap.
How quickly must I respond on HomeAdvisor?
Studies show responding within 5 minutes dramatically increases conversion on shared leads. Nearleap exclusivity eliminates this pressure.
What about lead disputes?
Both platforms have dispute processes. HomeAdvisor disputes require extensive documentation with variable approval rates. Nearleap credits back verified bad leads.
Can I target specific painting types?
Both allow preferences for interior/exterior and project sizes. Nearleap provides more detailed project information before claiming.
Feature Comparison
| Feature |  Nearleap | HomeAdvisor |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing Model | Fixed pricing per lead | Monthly fee + pay-per-lead |
| Lead Quality | Verified & qualified | Variable |
| Lead Exclusivity | Exclusive leads | Shared with 3-4 pros |
| Cost Per Lead | $19-25/lead | $15-100/lead |
| Contracts | No contracts | Monthly |
| Support | Priority support | Phone & email |
Detailed Analysis for Painters
Pricing & ROI
With average painting job values of $300-3,000, every lead counts. Nearleap's fixed pricing of $19-25 per lead gives you predictable costs and better ROI planning compared to HomeAdvisor's variable pricing.
Lead Quality
Nearleap verifies and qualifies every lead before delivery, ensuring you only pay for genuine opportunities. HomeAdvisor leads are often shared among multiple Painters, reducing your conversion rates.
Lead Exclusivity
With Nearleap, you get exclusive access to leads - no competing with 3-4 other Painters for the same job. This dramatically improves your close rate and reduces wasted time on bids you won't win.
Why Painters Choose Nearleap
Average Job Value
$300-3,000
Per project opportunity
Referral Partners
General contractors, Remodelers, Real estate agents
Common referral sources
Ready to Try Nearleap?
Join Painters who've switched from HomeAdvisor and are getting better leads at predictable prices. No contracts, cancel anytime.
Start Your Free Trial